The Constitutional Court of South Africa rules that asylum seekers may not submit subsequent applications following an initial refusal.
Director-General, Department of Home Affairs and others v Irankunda and Another
[2026] ZACC 18
Constitutional Court of South Africa
Mlambo, Kollapen, Mathopo, Mhlantla, Musi, Rogers, Savage, Tshiqi, Nicholls, JJ
12 May 2026
Reported by Faith Wanjiku & Derrick Omondi
Immigration Law–asylum seekers–subsequent applications–where Burundian nationals sought to lodge further asylum claims as sur place refugees after prior applications were rejected- whether the court had jurisdiction to hear the matter and to grant leave to appeal-whether the Act created the right for a failed asylum seeker to make subsequent applications-Refugees Act 130 of 1998, sections 1 and 21.
Brief facts
The respondents were Burundian nationals who fled Burundi between 2008 and 2012 and sought asylum in South Africa under the Refugees Act 130 of 1998(Act). Their initial asylum applications were rejected by the Refugee Status Determination Officer as manifestly unfounded and the decisions were confirmed by the Standing Committee. Following widespread political violence and instability that erupted in Burundi in 2015, the respondents lodged fresh asylum applications in 2018 claiming refugee status sur place, arguing that new circumstances in Burundi created a well-founded fear of persecution if they were returned. The Department rejected the applications and regarded the respondents as illegal foreigners liable for deportation under the Immigration Act.
The respondents approached the High Court on an urgent basis seeking interim relief compelling the Department of Home Affairs to issue them asylum seeker permits in terms of section 22 of the Refugees Act pending the determination of their fresh asylum applications. They argued that they had become refugees’ sur place because of the widespread political violence and persecution that erupted in Burundi in 2015 after their initial asylum applications had already been rejected. Returning them to Burundi before considering the new circumstances would violate the principle of non-refoulement contained in section 2 of the Act and international refugee laws, which prohibited the return of persons to countries where they face persecution or serious harm. The High Court granted interim relief on the basis that the respondents had a prima facie right to have their new claims considered. However, when determining the main application, the High Court dismissed their claims, holding that the respondents should instead have challenged the earlier rejections of their first asylum applications through judicial review proceedings rather than attempting to lodge fresh applications based on subsequent events.
The respondents appealed to the Supreme Court of Appeal which found in their favour. The court held that where an asylum seeker raised a genuine refugee sur place claim based on new facts or changed country conditions arising after the initial application, the authorities were obliged to consider that claim. The court reasoned that asylum seekers should not have been required to return to a country where they faced a real risk of persecution merely because their previous applications had been rejected before those changed circumstances arose. The Department was directed to accept and process the respondents’ subsequent asylum applications.
The Department then sought leave to appeal to the Constitutional Court claiming to raise an important constitutional and statutory question concerning whether the Act permitted failed asylum seekers to submit subsequent asylum applications after their original claims had been finally rejected. The applicants argued that while international law recognized refugees sur place as a category of refugees, it did not create a right to repeatedly submit new asylum applications indefinitely. They relied on the principle of finality in litigation and contended that once an asylum claim had been conclusively rejected and all review procedures exhausted, the applicant became an illegal foreigner subject to deportation under the Immigration Act. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the right of non-refoulement was a continuing substantive protection which remained available whenever new circumstances created a well-founded fear of persecution, and that the Act implicitly allowed subsequent applications provided they were not abusive or repetitive without new grounds.
Issues
- Whether the court had jurisdiction to hear the matter and, if so, whether leave to appeal should have been granted.
- Whether the Act created the right for a failed asylum seeker to make subsequent applications
Held by majority
- The matter raised the critical question of the interpretation of national legislation passed to give effect to South Africa’s international law obligations and raised an important legal question regarding subsequent asylum. The issues had significant implications for asylum seekers and the integrity of the asylum system. The court was satisfied that the matter engaged its constitutional jurisdiction and, on that basis, determined that granting leave to appeal was in the interests of justice.
- It was important to draw a distinction between first-time sur place refugees and subsequent asylum applicants. A refugee sur place was a person who was not a refugee when leaving their country of origin but later became one because of changed personal or political circumstances arising after departure. While international law recognized such first-time sur place claims, subsequent applications made after a final rejection stood on a different footing because they raised concerns relating to finality, abuse of process, and the integrity of the asylum system. Many foreign jurisdictions and the UNHCR treated subsequent applications through specialized statutory frameworks that imposed stricter thresholds, expedited procedures or mechanisms for rejecting abusive claims.
- In applying principles of statutory interpretation, the Act did not expressly provide for a right to lodge subsequent asylum applications after the rejection of an earlier claim. The Act defined an abusive application as one made after a prior refusal without substantial changes in circumstances that merely characterized certain applications as abusive and did not create a substantive right to reapply. The structure of the Act was designed primarily for first-time asylum applications and contained no dedicated procedural or substantive framework governing repeated applications, such as heightened evidentiary thresholds, expedited determination procedures or powers to summarily reject repetitive claims. If the Act had evidenced a right to make subsequent applications, then it should have at the very least described the right and what it entailed, as well as how it was to be exercised. In the court’s view, recognizing an unrestricted right to submit repeated applications would undermine the finality of asylum determinations and create a revolving door system capable of abuse.
- In interpreting the Act, the court applied constitutional principles which required legislation to be read consistently with the Bill of Rights and international law, including the principle of non-refoulement. Nevertheless those principles could not justify a strained interpretation unsupported by the text, structure, and purpose of the Act. International law recognized first-time sur place refugees, but found no universally recognized international right permitting failed asylum seekers to make repeated subsequent applications. The Act was designed only for first-time asylum applications and lacked the procedural and normative framework necessary to regulate subsequent claims fairly and effectively.
- The appeal was upheld as the Act did not confer a right on unsuccessful asylum seekers to submit subsequent asylum applications based on changed circumstances. However, the court was not deciding whether such a right should have existed as a matter of policy or constitutional compliance, noting that any such reform would require legislative amendment or a direct constitutional challenge to the Act.
Per Rogers and Nicholls, JJ (dissenting opinion)
- In agreement with the first judgement, the court had jurisdiction and it was in the interest of justice to have granted leave to appeal. Further, the Refugees Act should have been interpreted as permitting a second asylum application where there had been a material change in circumstances after the rejection of the first application. Denying repeat applications would create grave injustice, especially where conditions in an asylum seeker’s home country later deteriorated to the extent that deportation would expose them to persecution, violence, or death. The principle of non-refoulement under section 2 of the Act was paramount and protected fundamental constitutional rights such as dignity, life, equality, freedom and security of the person as well as the rights of children.
- The Act did not expressly prohibit subsequent asylum applications, and section 21 of the Act, which granted the right to apply for asylum, could not be interpreted as limiting an applicant to a single application. The interpretation was reinforced by the definition of an abusive application for asylum in section 1 of the Act, which described such an application as one made after the refusal of one or more prior applications without any substantial change in the applicant’s personal circumstances or the conditions in the country of origin.
- The wording clearly contemplated that subsequent applications were permissible where circumstances did materially change. Preventing repeat applications would irrationally discriminate between similarly situated asylum seekers and conflict with South Africa’s constitutional and international obligations, including obligations under the 1951 Refugee Convention, the OAU Convention, and child rights’ treaties.
- The Refugees Act ought to have been interpreted in a manner consistent with constitutional values and international refugee law by allowing subsequent asylum applications based on new or changed circumstances. While abuse of the asylum system was a legitimate concern, such abuse could be controlled through expedited procedures and stricter administrative mechanisms rather than by completely barring repeat applications. An interpretation prohibiting reapplications undermined the overriding principle of non-refoulement and exposed vulnerable individuals to unlawful refoulement and serious human rights violations.
Appeal allowed.
Orders
- Leave to appeal was granted.
- The Supreme Court of Appeal’s order was set aside and was replaced with an order dismissing the appeal.
- Each party was to bear its own costs.
Relevance to Kenyan Jurisprudence
Article 2(5) of the Constitution provides that the general rules of international law shall form part of the law of Kenya. The fact that non refoulement is a principle that has achieved the status of jus cogens and more to that is considered a principle of customary international law means that it has met the requirements of article 2(5) of the Constitution of Kenya.
Article 2(6) of the Constitution provides that any Treaty or convention ratified by Kenya shall form part of the law of Kenya under the constitution. Some of the applicable international law conventions that provide for the principle of non refoulement and which Kenya is a signatory to include; The Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees of 1951 and the Protocol Relating to the Convention of 1967, the OAU Convention of 1969, the African Charter of People and Human Rights amongst others. It is therefore evident from the foregoing, that the Kenyan law has embraced the principle of non refoulement, be it through domesticating the principle in its legislation or by ratifying conventions and treaties that prohibit any form of refoulement or through observance of generally accepted international principles of law.
Section 29(1) of the Refugees Act 2021 provides for the principle of non refoulement. The section provides that; No person shall be refused entry into Kenya, expelled, extradited from Kenya or returned to any other country or be subjected to any similar measure if, as a result of such refusal, expulsion, return or other measure, such person is compelled to return to or remain in a country where-
(a) the person may be subject to persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group or political opinion; or
(b) the person’s life, physical integrity or liberty would be threatened on account of external aggression, occupation, foreign domination or events seriously disturbing public order in part or whole of that country.
The benefit above may not, however, be claimed by a refugee or asylum seeker whom there are reasonable grounds for him or her being regarded as a danger to the national security of Kenya
The short title referring to the section 29(1) states ‘‘Non refoulement" leaving no room for ambiguity as to what it addresses, which is, to prohibit the refoulement of the persons where they are likely to face persecution or suffer other in human acts
Part III of the Refugees Act, 2021, addresses the criteria of application for refugee status. A person seeking refugee status must apply to the Commissioner for Refugee Affairs either directly or through an authorized officer, who is required to refer the asylum seeker to the relevant authority.
Upon receiving the application, the Commissioner may invite the applicant to present oral or documentary evidence in support of the asylum claim, with the applicant retaining the right to legal representation at their own expense.
The Commissioner is required to communicate the decision in writing, including reasons where the application is rejected, and may delegate interviews to departmental staff whose findings are reviewed by the Eligibility Panel before recommendations are made.
Pending determination of the application, the applicant is issued with a temporary pass, and the Commissioner is expected to determine the application within ninety days, subject to extension on reasonable grounds.
The Act further provides a right of appeal to the Appeals Committee and subsequently to the High Court for persons aggrieved by adverse decisions. Importantly, the Act protects asylum seekers from prosecution for unlawful entry or presence in Kenya while their applications and appeals are pending, provided the application was made in good faith.
Kenya’s Legal framework establishes a comprehensive asylum determination framework that safeguards the rights of asylum seekers through fair procedures, appeal mechanisms and protection from removal pending the determination of their claims. The reasoning further reinforces Kenya’s constitutional, statutory and international obligations to protect individuals from being returned to countries where they face persecution or serious harm.