NATIONAL BANK (K) LTD. Vs SWALEH ATHMAN MWAKUWAZA[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: civ suit 369 of 02 |
Date Delivered: 28 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Pamela Mwikali Tutui
Court: High Court at Mombasa
Parties: National Bank (K) Ltd. v Swaleh Athman Mwakuwaza
Advocates:
Citation: NATIONAL BANK (K) LTD. vs SWALEH ATHMAN MWAKUWAZA[2003] eKLR
Read More
Okello V Republic [2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: Criminal Appeal 172 of 2002 |
Date Delivered: 28 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Amrittal Bhagwanji Shah, Emmanuel Okello O'Kubasu
Court: Court of Appeal at Kisumu
Parties: Okello v Republic
Advocates:
Citation: Okello v Republic [2003] eKLR
Okello v Republic
Court of Appeal, at Kisumu March 28, 2003
Shah & O’Kubasu JJ A
Criminal Appeal No 172 of 2002
(Appeal from an order of the High Court of Kenya at Busia (Ringera J)
dated 10th May, 2002 in High Court Criminal Appeal No 53 of 2001)
Criminal Practice and Procedure - appeal – summary rejection of appeal – petition disclosing grounds other than excessive sentence and insufficient evidence – whether appellant entitled to full hearing of appeal – grounds upon which summary rejection can be ordered - power of the Court of Appeal in an appeal against a summary rejection.
The appellant was charged and convicted in a magistrate’s court for the offence of causing grievous harm contrary to s. 234 of the Penal Code. His appeal to the High Court was summarily rejected. He appealed to the Court of Appeal against summary rejection of his appeal.
Held:
1. The power of summary rejection of appeal under s. 352 (2) of the Criminal Procedure Code is strictly limited to cases where the appeal is brought only on the ground that the conviction is against the weight of evidence or that the sentence is excessive.
2. Since the petition disclosed other grounds other than excessive sentence, the appellant was entitled to the benefit of a full hearing by the Superior Court.
3. It would not be proper for the appellate court, in this case, to consider the full merits of the appellant’s grounds in his petition to the Superior Court.
Appeal allowed. Appeal remitted to hearing before the Superior Court.
Cases
1. John Mwangi v R [1983] KLR 652; [1982-88] 1 KAR 367
2. Okang v Republic [1982–88] 1 KAR 276
3. Obiri v R [1981] KLR 493
Statutes
1. Penal Code (cap 63) section 234
2. Criminal Procedure Code (cap 75) section 352(2)
3. Appellate Jurisdiction Act (cap 9) section 3(2)
4. Court of Appeal Rules (cap 9 Sub Leg) rule 32 (2)
Advocates
Mr Wanga for the Appellant
Mr Musau for the Respondent
Read More
JASUMATI DHIRAJLAL SAVANI Vs CHUNILAL M. SAVANI[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: civ case 69 of 02 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: John walter Onyango Otieno
Court: High Court at Mombasa
Parties: JASUMATI DHIRAJLAL SAVANI vs CHUNILAL M. SAVANI
Advocates:
Citation: JASUMATI DHIRAJLAL SAVANI vs CHUNILAL M. SAVANI[2003] eKLR
Read More
EDWIN OCHIENG OYOKO Vs REPUBLIC[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: crim app 303 of 00 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Amraphael Mbogholi-Msagha
Court: High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
Parties: EDWIN OCHIENG OYOKO vs REPUBLIC
Advocates:
Citation: EDWIN OCHIENG OYOKO vs REPUBLIC[2003] eKLR
Read More
NAHASHON KIPKURUI LANGAT V REPUBLIC [2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: Criminal Appeal 111 of 2001 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Jessie Wanjiku Lesiit
Court: High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
Parties: NAHASHON KIPKURUI LANGAT v REPUBLIC
Advocates:
Citation: NAHASHON KIPKURUI LANGAT v REPUBLIC [2003] eKLR
Read More
PATRICK DICKSON RAJULA Vs KENYA COMMERCIAL BANK LTD. & 2 OTHERS[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: civ case 397 of 02 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: John walter Onyango Otieno
Court: High Court at Mombasa
Parties: Patrick Dickson Rajula v Kenya Commercial Bank Ltd. & 2 Others
Advocates:
Citation: PATRICK DICKSON RAJULA vs KENYA COMMERCIAL BANK LTD. & 2 OTHERS[2003] eKLR
Read More
BENJAMINA KOMEN Vs REPUBLIC[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: crim app 131 of 00[1] |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Jessie Wanjiku Lesiit
Court: High Court at Nakuru
Parties: BENJAMINA KOMEN vs REPUBLIC
Advocates:
Citation: BENJAMINA KOMEN vs REPUBLIC[2003] eKLR
Read More
NELLIWA BUILDERS & CIVIL ENGINEERS Vs KENYATTA NATIONAL HOSPITAL[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: civ suit 1675 of 02[1] |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Richard Charles Namasaka Kuloba
Court: High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
Parties: Nelliwa Builders & Civil Engineers v Kenyatta National Hospital
Advocates:
Citation: NELLIWA BUILDERS & CIVIL ENGINEERS vs KENYATTA NATIONAL HOSPITAL[2003] eKLR
Read More
KIBO JIMMY KITAVI Vs REPUBLIC[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: crim app 333 of 02 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Pamela Mwikali Tutui
Court: High Court at Mombasa
Parties: KIBO JIMMY KITAVI vs REPUBLIC
Advocates:
Citation: KIBO JIMMY KITAVI vs REPUBLIC[2003] eKLR
Read More
JOSEPH KIMACHIA WAMWIRI Vs JOSEPH KIMACHIA WAMWIRI[2003] EKLR
|
Case Number: div cause 45 of 02 |
Date Delivered: 27 Mar 2003 |
Judge: Joyce Adhiambo Aluoch
Court: High Court at Nairobi (Milimani Law Courts)
Parties: Joseph Kimachia Wamwiri v Joseph Kimachia Wamwiri
Advocates:
Citation: JOSEPH KIMACHIA WAMWIRI vs JOSEPH KIMACHIA WAMWIRI[2003] eKLR
Read More